Proactive Approach to Tree Vandalism
This policy will give Council a framework for how to deal with tree vandalism incidences, what are your thoughts on taking a proactive approach to this issue?
This online discussion forum has concluded. You can still browse the site but the discussion area will no longer accept new comments or votes.
Relates to
document:
Draft Tree Vandalism Policy (510.2 KB)
banksia Comment 1 16 May 2008, 11:29 AM
I wholeheartedly support PSC taking a proactive approach to this issue. As drafted I think the Policy appears well thought out. I'm sure there will be a few amendments suggested but I believe the important thing is to get the Policy in place as quickly as possible so that both public and Council expectations for actions and outcomes are firmly understood and fulfilled. I believe the law covering this issue is clear. Enforcement may not be popular amongst residents when they are directly affected but if there is no confusion or misunderstanding of what that enforcement entails up front, the public debate in the press might be avoided. It does serve the purpose of highlighting awareness but it can have a divisive effect on the community.
I wholeheartedly support PSC taking a proactive approach to this issue. As drafted I think the Policy appears well thought out. I'm sure there will be a few amendments suggested but I believe the important thing is to get the Policy in place as quickly as possible so that both public and Council expectations
more…Your Concious Comment 1.1 29 May 2008, 4:59 PM
PSC are one of the main perpatrator of this sort of Vandilism, have a look at One mile beach headland as an example.... If they are making no money from it, it's called vandilism, if they are making money it's good for the community,in the end, both are killing trees, so who is right & who is wrong ???? it's funny how people change laws to suit themselves or their situations.
What they did at Boat Harbour was a waste of rate payers money & should of been spent on more important thing such as paying the legal costs they have inccured from bad business management from the past. If you work with the community, problems like that can be solved and not cause more problems, by putting more plants there.
Personally, the same problem will come back to haunt the PSC in another 10yrs, with the same outcome.
how many of these councillors have cleared such things ????
I think a few would be guilty of the same thing.
PSC are one of the main perpatrator of this sort of Vandilism, have a look at One mile beach headland as an example.... If they are making no money from it, it's called vandilism, if they are making money it's good for the community,in the end, both are killing trees, so who is right & who is wrong ????
more…ggeer Comment 2 18 May 2008, 7:23 PM
I agree this is a good poicy. We should come down hard on these vandals
martha Comment 3 23 May 2008, 9:06 PM
I think we should clamp down on these hooligans. The fines could be bigger as these are wealthy people and can afford them and their houses are worth more with better views. This makes blocking the views even more important. Go hard Council!
unclerob Comment 4 2 Jun 2008, 12:04 PM
If people break the law then prosecute them - fair enough. But this policy of blocking views penalises neighburs an visitors and just about anyone who takes a walk or drive in the area. Council should enforce the existing rules and not penalise the entire community becasue they cannot catch the guilty people.
banksia Comment 4.1 22 Jul 2008, 8:56 AM
This would be an ideal solution in an ideal world. Unfortunately, we know that Council doesn't have the resources to police all public property or "catch the guilty people." It's therefore incumbent upon us, the residents to assist. Again unfortunately, we don't. The majority of incidents of vandalism (of all types) are witnessed by someone but the 'ozzie' ethic that we don't dob on each other prevents people from stepping forward to report or blow the whistle. Until that ethic is overcome the best answer is to erect something that says 'look what someone has done to your environment ... if you saw it happened step forward and tell us about it, otherwise look at this ugliness for a few months.' I don't view it as a penalty or punishment at all, just a reminder that something natural and nice stood here a short while ago, and now it doesn't. It's the best we can do in a less than ideal world.
This would be an ideal solution in an ideal world. Unfortunately, we know that Council doesn't have the resources to police all public property or "catch the guilty people." It's therefore incumbent upon us, the residents to assist. Again unfortunately, we don't. The majority of incidents of vandalism
more…